Thursday, March 4, 2010

5-10-20 Rule: Taking Another Shot at First Solar (FSLR)

We played FSLR when they announced earnings last time, and after making one quick adjustment we profited 52%.  Here is quick update on fundamentals from Credit Suisse:


"C4Q09 results vs expectations. FSLR reported 4Q09 Rev/EPS of $641.3mm and $1.65 above CS estimate of $588.7mm/$1.55 and street estimates of $577.6mm/$1.51.Upside relative to our estimates was driven by (i) Higher panel production; (ii) Higher system completions; (iii) Lower tax rates; (iv) Offset by lower gross margins and higher opex.

4Q09 key metrics. (i) Module GM of ~49.3% was lower than guidance of ~50- 51%, company claimed due to lower pricing for 21MW AC Blythe project, need also 10-K color; we think energy from the Blythe project was priced below 2007 MPR of $9.84c/kWh; (ii) 4Q shipments were 311MW (up 6% q/q), slightly better than our estimates of 293MW as panel efficiencies and line throughputs were higher than our model; (iii) We estimate there was ~45.6MW of system installs in 4Q09 (comprising of Blythe and Sarnia projects) for a systems revenue of $151mm in 4Q09 (we will revise this after company’s 10-K is filed), this was likely ~$15mm more than our estimate; (iv) We estimate module ASPs were $1.66/watt in C4Q09 (down ~4.4% q/q) lower than our assumption of $1.70/watt (contributed to GM miss mentioned above); (v) Panel manufacturing costs were 84c/watt (down 1% q/q) – but “core” manufacturing cost excluding ramp costs was down 2c/watt q/q to 82c, which was better than our estimate of 84c/watt.


Valuation. We have lowered our CY10 EPS from $6.58 to $6.25 to reflect a more conservative currency assumption of $1.35. We are lowering our price target from $132 to $115, representing an average of 20x CY10 EPS and 15x our new CY11 EPS of $7 (we were at $7.5 before)."

Going with my theses that many stocks are likely to stay range-bound over coming months and implied volatility will come down further, I am selling the following iron condor on FSLR:

- Buy to open April $125 calls

- Sell to open April $120 calls
- Buy to open April $90 puts
- Sell to open April $95 puts

I just filled the order for $1.55 credit.  Does the trade meet 5-10-20 test?

5% - No more than 5% of your portfolio - Check
10% - Trade has 12% cushion on the upside and 14% cushion on the downside - Check
20% - Max profit on the trade is 45% return after commissions - Check

For more on my 5-10-20 rule, go to 5-10-20

Good luck!